The mining industry has recently suffered from several high-profile mineral resource overestimations. The primary cause of these failures is a lack of understanding of the controls of mineralization and a resulting optimistic classification. A contributing factor to this phenomenon is an MRMR estimation workflow that has artificial barriers constructed between stages and practitioners. These transition stages can be summarized as follows:
- Geological Information to Drill Logger (defines intervals and sampling strategy)
- Database to Geological Modeller (defines practical geological limits to mineralization)
- Geological Model to Resource Estimator (defines the grade within blocks)
- Resource Estimation to Reserve Definition (defines recovery assumptions, stope and or pit optimization etc.)
- Reserve Model to Cashflow Modeller (defines economic results derived from the rocks)
Conventionally, the practitioner responsible for one phase of work does not look at the process or resulting output from the previous or subsequent phases. For example, the Resource Estimator has limited discussions with the Drill Logger or the Mining Engineer responsible for the Reserve definition. It is generally assumed that the product provided by the previous operator is “true”, and sources of uncertainty are not called out or quantified. Unfortunately, errors often propagate and impacts become invisible to the practitioner focused on their assigned stage. Reviewing a process from a previous or following stage will often reveal fatal flaws that require correction. Case studies will be provided to illustrate how issues with the mineral inventory can be brought to light with constructive coordination between professionals between stages. Examples include:
- Management of missing assays (force zeroes or not)
- Identification of appropriate geological modelling parameters (grade/lithology/alteration/other)
- Identification of unreasonable extrapolations and “overpowered intervals”
- Mine shapes that are not realistically economic
- Metallurgical assumptions that are no longer coherent with head grades
Working within a small multidisciplinary team with a culture of cooperation and equal status increases the chances of robust and reliable Mineral Resources and Mineral Reserves.