Christopher Emerson, FAusIMM, Senior Vice President, Exploration and Geology, Pan American Silver Corp.
Fred R. Pletcher, Partner and Chair of the National Mining Group, Borden Ladner Gervais LLP
Christopher Wright, P.Geo., Vice President, Mineral Resource Management, Pan American Silver Corp.
The presentation will present geological, engineering and legal perspectives on the topic.
Canadian public mining issuers pursuing satellite deposits, phased mine development or alternative development approaches face significant disclosure risks under National Instrument 43-101 (NI 43-101), primarily stemming from the instrument's restrictions on combining studies of different confidence levels within a single technical report.
NI 43-101 technical reports are designed to present a single, preferred development scenario rather than multiple competing options or trade-off studies. The rationale is straightforward — issuers should demonstrate a clear path forward to develop a project and illustrate the funding required to achieve that objective. This becomes problematic, however, when an issuer wishes to disclose development of satellite deposits, a staged expansion of an operating mine or is considering alternative approaches to mine development, any of which have been studied at a lower confidence level than the main project.
The most significant constraint involves disclosure of inferred mineral resources. NI 43-101 explicitly prohibits including inferred resources in pre-feasibility studies (PFS) or feasibility studies (FS). Inferred resources may only appear in preliminary economic assessments (PEAs) that are independent of any PFS, FS, or life-of-mine plan. This creates a practical barrier: if a satellite deposit or expansion phase relies wholly or partly on inferred resources, the issuer cannot publicly disclose economic analyses, cash flow models, or production rates that integrate those inferred-resource-based outcomes with the mineral-reserve-based outcomes of the main study.
The proposed US$1.9 billion expansion and development of Pan American Silver Corp.’s La Colorada property, located in Zacatecas, Mexico, will be presented as a case study on the challenges in disclosure posed by a complex phased mine expansion. The La Colorada development is comprised of: continuing production from an existing underground silver vein mine with mineral reserves and a >30 year operating history; the simultaneous development of newly identified high-grade silver veins in the eastern area of the existing mine, mainly comprised of inferred mineral resources; the concurrent development using conventional long-hole open stoping of higher grade portions of a large-scale zinc-lead-silver skarn deposit below the existing mine, comprised of indicated and inferred mineral resources; and the construction of a new, 15,000 tonnes per day plant. Total estimated mine life following completion of the new plant is 37 years.
Best disclosure practices under NI 43-101 with respect to satellite deposits, phased development and development alternatives will be discussed, including use of Item 24 disclosure in NI 43-101 technical reports, advancing add-on studies to a higher confidence level before combining them with the main study and forgoing an integrated economic presentation.
Current disclosure requirements in respect of satellite deposits, phased development and development alternatives reveal a tension between Canadian public mining issuers presenting a holistic project vision to investors and current regulatory prohibition on blending reserve-based and inferred-resource-based economics. As amendments to NI 43-101 are considered by the Canadian Securities Administrators, greater flexibility in combining different study levels and disclosing alternates analyses may improve disclosure to investors in complex expansion or development scenarios.